Carol Off: on how she’s only recently discovered the depth of her patriotism

My hunch is, almost everyone reading this knows who Carol Off is: host of “As It Happens” on CBC Radio for a decade and a half; author of five books, plus a new one, ”True Patriot Love: Reporting from the Front Lines of Canadian Sovereignty,” which chronicles her own life story along a kind of parallel track with Canada’s own history. One of Off’s most interesting discoveries is that, for one of Canada’s greatest ever foreign correspondents, she loves her home and native land a lot more than she thought.

Steve Paikin: How are you personally navigating your relationship with the United States these days?

Carol Off: I was just recently doing an interview on stage with American author, Jodi Picoult. When we began, she said, “I just want to start by saying, I’m sorry. We’re all sorry!” But I also hear from Americans who say, “Look, you guys have to grow a thicker skin. Trump’s just trolling you. Don’t take it so seriously.” And I say, “Well, if you were told that you were going to possibly be invaded, you wouldn’t say, ‘That’s just Donald talking.’” We know that there are very deep histories to this, and this is just the most bald-faced and cruel way to do it.

SP: How about travelling to the US?

CO: Cut out completely. Definitely not since COVID. I have just decided not to go at all.

SP: Let’s turn the magnifying glass around and look at us, because you say Canada has not just a chance, but also an obligation to be a beacon of civil society and liberal democracy in North America, and I presume you say that because our friends to the South are not being that right now. Why do you think we have this obligation?

CO: Because we are a liberal democracy and we all have a role to play in pulling our system of values, our system of politics back from the brink. And I don’t just think about the United States when I say that. I see what’s happening in Europe, and what we’ve seen recently in elections in Germany. We see an erosion of some really key values of constitutional democracies like our own. And Canada is one of the few countries that’s holding the line. That’s why we’re having this enormous reaction from around the world of “Go Canada!” I was just recently reading a blog from a Brit who said, “I would kill to be a Canadian” because they’re standing up to the bully in the playground, standing up for values, standing up for things that matter.

SP: You tell us in your book that “Something has happened in Canada that I haven’t seen before: an utter rejection of that unhealthy dependence, a will to nationhood from a generation that wants to light its own flame rather than be moths drawn to the American one. I’m seeing an energy and self-assurance that was present only as a sketch.” Keep going. What are you seeing?

CO: I was just recently talking to Margaret Atwood, who was saying that she remembers a poll in the 1960s where Canadians were asked whether Canada and the United States were very different countries. And most people said no, they’re very similar. And then the next question was, ‘Do you want Canada to join the United States?’ And the answer was overwhelmingly, no. We didn’t want to be Americans, but we had no sense of who we were. What I have seen in the past year is suddenly, all the things that I have watched over the decades have coalesced into this sense of, ‘Now I get it; now I know who we are.’ It often takes a crisis to do that, doesn’t it?

SP: But there are plenty of people in our country who still do not agree with you. Do you take into account the fact that maybe 20 per cent of Canadians really don’t like what this country turned into after a decade of Justin Trudeau as Prime Minister? Many of them would be all too happy to join the United States. What do you say to them?

CO:I would have a lot of questions for them about what it is you see the country is about. What is it that you value about Canada? Its constitution? Clearly not. It’s  rule of law? Its diversity? Its immigration, multiculturalism, bilingualism, its relationship with Indigenous people? All of those things would probably evaporate if we were to join the United States. And so I have to ask, what is the country that you would like us to be? There is a movement of ethnic nationalism in the United States that we don’t share. And I look to those 80 per cent of Canadians who would probably join me in this, that we believe in being patriotic. We believe in a love of country that is based on an idea and not on an identity. And that’s the key difference.

SP: Let me follow up because I think the 20 per cent would say, Carol, you don’t love freedom enough. ‘You might like government intervention in our lives and our economy too much,’ and that’s where they want to draw a line.

CO: I’m not sure it is about freedom from their point of view. I think it’s about identity and about a desire to return to a Canada that I don’t believe ever really existed — someplace where we had a kind of ethnic singularity, where we were all of the same breed. That was the sort of “golden age.” Well, it wasn’t. The kind of country we want: one that takes care of each other, that has health care, that has good education, that has a future.

SP: In our lifetime, we have seen, for example, Pierre Trudeau introduce his Third Way initiative, which tried to de-emphasize American involvement and find other markets. Didn’t go anywhere. Now Mark Carney is giving it a go, trying to find new connections, new ways of doing things, so we don’t have to be so reliant on the U.S. What do you think his prospects are?

CO: This is a really important question. We’ll soon find out, right? What’s different, I think, is that the captains of industry in this country may have sobered up a bit. I think that they were really intoxicated by the idea that we could have this North American free market zone, and by virtue of that, we could make a lot of money, and they didn’t see that much else mattered.

SP: Well, it mostly worked pretty well as long as there was a sane person in the Oval Office.

CO: Well, it did, and it didn’t. The erosion was profound. We didn’t own our enterprises. We have become one of the most unproductive G-7 countries and even G-20 countries. Nothing was reinvested back into our technology, into our plants. All profits left the country, because they didn’t need to invest in Canada. And so we were sitting ducks for what has happened with Donald J. Trump.

SP: You call the year 1985 an inflection point for the country and for you. Your son Joel was eight years old then, and you say you remember wondering if he would grow up to be Canadian or some version of American. We’re more than forty years later — what’s the verdict?

CO: He’s so strongly Canadian. We spent all of our free time seeing Canada. He now goes every year — some crazy canoe trip, someplace in Canada, so he can see all the national parks before he dies. And he’s imparted that to his daughters. My granddaughters have a really strong understanding of embracing contradiction, for example, loving the country and knowing what happened in residential schools. We can hold two ideas in our heads at the same time. That’s the strength of Canada.

SP: There was one line in your book, and I must say I had a rather visceral reaction to it. You wrote, “How I learned to truly patriotically love this country.” And my initial reaction to that was to ask, ‘You mean you haven’t always truly patriotically loved this country?’

CO: No, I haven’t. I took it for granted. I didn’t know what mattered. I came home from all my travels — I covered wars, genocides, ethnic cleansing, things blowing up all over the place — and I would come home and I’d be so grateful to be home. But I didn’t know what I had. I didn’t know why it mattered. And I thank Donald Trump for that moment when I realized what it is to truly patriotically love this country. I now realize what it is to have a civic love of your country, to love what it’s about, even as you see its flaws. I want to hold on to what matters, and I want to question what has failed, and push for those things to get better. I want to take on that role of civic responsibility because the alternative — I can see it in the United States. This is our chance to avoid that car crash. I think it it’s my responsibility to step up, to say, I understand what I’ve got here and I’m not going to let it go.